Best Rye Whiskies We've Reviewed — The Liquor Connoisseur's Ranked List
- connoisseurofliquo
- 23 hours ago
- 2 min read
Rye whiskey is America's most underappreciated category. Crystal and Roger have reviewed it more thoroughly than almost any other podcast — from cask strength Monongahela-style expressions to rum-finished ryes. This is the definitive ranked list.
🥇 #1 — Michter's Single Barrel Straight Rye | World's Most Admired Whiskey, Two Years Running
Named World's Most Admired Whiskey by Drinks International two consecutive years. Crystal and Roger tasted and confirmed the title is earned. Balanced, complex, and genuinely excellent at its price point. The benchmark for American single barrel rye.
🥈 #2 — PonFEIGH Cask Strength Monongahela Rye | 120-Proof Pennsylvania History in a Glass
The smoothest high-proof rye Crystal and Roger have reviewed. Pennsylvania Monongahela style, single barrel, cask strength — from the birthplace of American whiskey. The most surprising rye experience in recent TLC history.
🥉 #3 — WhistlePig 12-Year World Rye | The Premium Standard
Crystal and Roger asked the $125 question and answered it: yes, WhistlePig 12-Year is worth it for a special occasion pour. Canadian-American blended rye with genuine complexity and a finish that earns every penny.
#4 — Widow Jane Apple Wood Rye | The Brooklyn Statement Rye
Apple wood barrel finishing on a high-rye mashbill — a bold choice that works. Widow Jane makes the case that rye and unconventional finishing belong together.
#5 — RY3 Rum Cask Finished Rye | The Experiment That Delivered
Do rye and rum cask finishing belong together? Crystal and Roger said yes. RY3 takes the spice of rye and adds tropical sweetness from the rum barrel without overwhelming either character.
Also Reviewed: Wild Turkey 101 (best value rye-influenced bourbon), Sazerac Rye, Knob Creek Rye
🥃 Taste These Spirits in Person
Crystal and Roger lead private spirits tasting experiences. Corporate from $1,500. In-home from $500. Virtual nationwide.
Comments